Terms like narcissist, borderline, gaslighting, and trauma get thrown around constantly now.
Actually understanding what they mean is a lot harder.
Dr. Adam Rodriguez is a psychologist whose clinical background includes community mental health, hospitals, college counseling, and forensic psychotherapy in state and federal prison systems.
In this episode of Maxwell’s Kitchen, Adam and I get deep into borderline personality disorder, narcissistic personality disorder, Cluster B disorders, splitting, projection, gaslighting, trauma, identity, relationships, medication, and what psychotherapy is actually trying to accomplish.
It is a long conversation, but a lot of it comes back to one idea: people are complicated, diagnoses are imperfect, and understanding why somebody behaves a certain way usually requires looking beneath the behavior itself.
In This Episode
Borderline personality disorder
Narcissistic personality disorder
Cluster B personality disorders
Healthy versus pathological narcissism
Fear of abandonment
Splitting and black-and-white thinking
Projection
Gaslighting and power
Insecurity and grandiosity
Identity and sense of self
Childhood development
Trauma and neglect
Sexual abuse and its psychological effects
Relationship patterns
Boundaries
Diagnosis and misdiagnosis
BPD versus bipolar disorder and anxiety
Psychiatric medication
The chemical imbalance model
Genetics and mental illness
How psychotherapy works
Why therapy is relational
Cutting unhealthy people out of your life
Relationships after trauma
Guest
Dr. Adam Rodriguez, PsyD
Adam is a psychologist whose clinical experience includes community mental health, hospital settings, college counseling services, and forensic psychotherapy in the California correctional system and federal prison system.
His work has included psychotherapy, clinical training, supervision, and research involving identity, relationships, psychological development, and the ways people understand themselves and each other.
Borderline Personality Disorder and Diagnosis
We start with borderline personality disorder and the broader category of Cluster B personality disorders.
One of Adam’s first points is that people do not necessarily walk into therapy saying, “I have borderline personality disorder. Please treat it.”
They may come in because they are depressed.
Maybe their relationship is falling apart.
Their partner wants them to see someone.
They are constantly having problems at work.
Something is wrong, but the diagnosis may not be obvious at first.
That makes personality disorders particularly complicated because the behaviors can overlap with other conditions.
An intense emotional episode can resemble bipolar disorder, anxiety, depression, or something else entirely depending on the circumstances and how little time a clinician has spent with the person.
Adam emphasizes that understanding someone takes time.
A diagnosis based on a brief snapshot can miss what is actually happening underneath.
Narcissism Is Not Automatically a Disorder
Narcissism is another term that gets used far more casually than its clinical meaning.
Adam makes an important distinction between narcissistic traits and narcissistic personality disorder.
Everybody needs some degree of healthy narcissism.
You need enough confidence to believe you are worth something, pursue a job, recover from rejection, take risks, and survive setbacks without completely falling apart.
The problem is when those traits become rigid or destructive.
Someone can appear extraordinarily confident while actually operating from deep insecurity.
That insecurity may show up as grandiosity, constant self-promotion, superiority, defensiveness, or an inability to tolerate criticism.
What looks like extreme confidence from the outside can sometimes be compensation for something much more fragile underneath.
Splitting and Black-and-White Thinking
One of the most interesting parts of the conversation is Adam’s explanation of splitting.
Splitting is essentially a way of separating experiences into opposing categories.
Good or bad.
Right or wrong.
Perfect or terrible.
We all do versions of this.
Sports rivalries are built on it. Politics thrives on it. Even something as stupid as choosing between cats and dogs can turn into an artificial binary.
You are allowed to like both.
For somebody operating in a more extreme borderline state, though, splitting can become a major part of relationships.
Someone may be idealized as the greatest person in the world and then, after a disappointment or perceived rejection, suddenly become completely worthless.
The middle disappears.
That makes relationships incredibly unstable because normal human flaws become difficult to integrate into a more complete picture of the other person.
Projection and Gaslighting
We also talk about projection.
Adam describes projection as taking something difficult or unacceptable within yourself and locating it in somebody else.
Instead of confronting your own anger, insecurity, jealousy, or fear, it becomes the other person’s problem.
That leads us into gaslighting, another term that has become extremely common.
Adam distinguishes gaslighting from ordinary disagreement or even simple dishonesty.
In the way he describes it, gaslighting involves repeatedly causing another person to question their own perception, memory, or judgment.
The result can become a power dynamic.
If I can make you stop trusting yourself, you may begin relying more heavily on me to tell you what happened, what is true, or what you should believe.
That is where the behavior becomes much more damaging than simply arguing over who remembered something correctly.
Trauma, Neglect, and Identity
Childhood experiences take up a substantial part of the conversation.
Adam explains that trauma does not create one predictable outcome.
There is no simple formula where a particular childhood experience automatically produces a particular personality disorder.
But early relationships matter.
Children develop their sense of themselves partly through their relationships with caregivers and the people around them.
When there is severe instability, neglect, abuse, or an inability to safely process what is happening, building a coherent identity can become more difficult.
Adam discusses this in relation to borderline personality organization, including the difficulty some people experience integrating conflicting feelings about themselves and other people.
Someone can love another person and still be angry with them.
A parent can be caring in one moment and disappointing in another.
Learning to hold those competing truths together is part of psychological development.
When that integration becomes difficult, people may fall back on more rigid ways of understanding themselves and their relationships.
Relationships and Boundaries
A lot of this episode comes back to relationships.
People often say they need to completely “work on themselves” before they can be in a relationship.
Adam challenges that idea.
Much of human growth happens through relationships with other people.
That does not mean every relationship should be preserved.
There are circumstances where setting firm boundaries or cutting someone out of your life may be necessary.
An abusive parent does not automatically deserve unlimited access to an adult child simply because they are family.
The larger point is that becoming healthier does not usually mean isolating yourself until you emerge as a perfectly repaired person.
Everybody enters relationships with history, fears, insecurities, expectations, and baggage.
The question is whether two people can build something where those vulnerabilities can exist without constantly making each other worse.
What Psychotherapy Is Actually Doing
Adam’s explanation of psychotherapy is one of my favorite parts of the episode.
Therapy is not simply paying someone to give you advice.
A therapist telling you what to do is not necessarily the point.
Adam describes psychotherapy as something that happens through the relationship itself.
Thoughts matter, but so do emotions, physical reactions, patterns, expectations, and what happens between two people while they are sitting in the room together.
That relationship can reveal patterns that are difficult to see alone.
How do you react when you feel misunderstood?
What happens when somebody disappoints you?
Do you immediately withdraw?
Become angry?
Idealize someone and then tear them down?
Assume rejection before it happens?
Those patterns can show up inside therapy just as they show up everywhere else.
That gives the therapist and the person in therapy an opportunity to actually experience and examine them together.
Medication and the “Chemical Imbalance” Idea
Later in the conversation, we get into psychiatric medication and the popular idea that mental illness can simply be explained as a chemical imbalance.
Adam pushes back on that explanation as being far too simple.
Psychiatric medications can affect neurotransmitters and can improve mood or reduce symptoms for some people.
But the fact that a medication helps does not automatically prove that the original problem was caused by a deficiency of the chemical affected by that medication.
His analogy is straightforward: taking Advil may help a headache, but that does not mean the headache was caused by an Advil deficiency.
Mental health involves biology, genetics, environment, relationships, development, experience, and many other factors interacting with each other.
Reducing all of that to one chemical explanation may be comforting because it is simple.
Human beings usually are not.
Why This Conversation Matters
This episode started because I wanted to better understand borderline personality disorder and narcissism.
It ended up becoming a much broader conversation about how people develop, why relationships become dysfunctional, what diagnoses can and cannot tell us, and what therapy is actually trying to change.
There are no neat answers here.
That is probably the point.
The more you understand psychology, the harder it becomes to reduce another person to a label.
Useful Links
Dr. Adam Rodriguez
http://www.dradamrodriguez.com/
More Interviews
Borderline Personality Disorder, Trauma & Psychedelic Therapy with Zara Roth
https://maxwellskitchenpodcast.com/maxwells-kitchen-podcast/2022/10/20-episode-92-zara-roth
Zara Roth approaches some of the same subjects from another angle, including borderline personality disorder, DBT, trauma, emotional regulation, anxiety, isolation, and psychedelic-assisted therapy.
Sex Therapy, Relationships & Intimacy with Alana Ogilvie
https://maxwellskitchenpodcast.com/maxwells-kitchen-podcast/is-sex-therapy-right-for-your-relationship
Another conversation about therapy, relationships, communication, intimacy, and what happens when the patterns between two people stop working.

